assignment 2 instruction is there, samples are there, the template that you will use is there; and relevant lectures 3 and 4.
you have to follow the instruction and see the lecutres , i.e. the slide where it discusses with tables on trainig plan etc. those are samples and you can decide which method is good one and you can adopt one but your assignment should be unique in writing
its uploaded and is in order; starting from instruction for assignment2, then TMCE template that you will use for this assignment; the samples that have done similiar activity; the assignment 1 which has data for the training location, org, trainees # number; and finally lectures, on the lecture look at the table slides where it explain on the design plan and how its developed, etc.
Remember all six steps are relevant and one builds upon other. So, assignment 2 will utilize the assignment 1 data, read through the instructions carefully and the lectures have all the information you need to complete the second assignment. The template is there to fill in and the samples can be used as an example
Plan for Diagnosing Training Needs
Instructions for Assignment 2
Use the “TMCE Assign2 Needs Diagnosis Template ” to conduct a training needs diagnosis. This document is available in the “Assignment 2 Materials” folder of the Online Library.
Please address the following:
· Instrument design
· Information collection procedures
· Information processing
· Information analysis
· Information sources—including interviews, observations, and records within the agency, feedback from the community/clients, and review of current professional literature
If you are focusing on a real-life group of potential trainees, carry out as much of the real diagnosis as possible prior to submitting this assignment. Please note that this is not research. Training is part of normal human resource management in your organization/agency.
Training Needs Diagnosis would ideally be completed before planning your training; most people in the class will probably not have the opportunity to do a real-life diagnosis with interviews, observations, etc. before assignment 2 is due. Hence, assignment 2 should be a PLAN for how one would conduct a relevant learning needs diagnosis. Note that since diagnosis does involve review of existing documents and informal interviews, you may be able to include some actual ‘findings’ depending on what documents (e.g. reports) you can access and to whom you might talk.
After you have gathered the required information, summarize your findings and identify priority areas of skills, knowledge, and attitudes needed by the potential trainees to undertake their jobs.
Make sure to use the “TMCE Assign2 Needs Diagnosis Template ” for this assignment.
Recruitment and Involvement of Trainees
William Brieger, MPH, CHES, DrPH
Johns Hopkins University
The material in this video is subject to the copyright of the owners of the material and is being provided for educational purposes under
rules of fair use for registered students in this course only. No additional copies of the copyrighted work may be made or distributed.
awjoyan-trv
Highlight
2
Continued
Who Participates? Who Decides?
Is training
organized …
In-house?
Externally?
(if an
invitation
is received)
3
Who Participates? Who Decides?
Criteria: formal and informal
Who is eligible according
personnel policy?
Who is qualified in technical terms?
Who has influence, connections, or seniority?
Whose “turn” is it?
4
What Are the Incentives to Attend Training?
Both professional and personal
Linked with promotion criteria
Opportunity for self-actualization
Travel and per diem are enticing
Workshops offer a chance to SHOP
Recognition upon return
Sometimes the wrong people attend for the wrong
reasons
5
And What Happens on Return?
Are there opportunities to practice new skills?
Is there policy and supervisory support?
Are there adequate resources?
Will there be jealousy and lack of cooperation among co-
workers?
Can multiplier effects be achieved by sharing and
training others?
6
Ensuring
Appropriate Recruitment
Spell out very clearly
in all promotional
literature
The desired
qualifications of
potential trainees
What the trainee
is expected to do
upon returning to
work Nurse aides are often trained
on the job in private clinics;
they are least likely to receive
training unless organizers
specify their attendance
7
Appropriate Recruitment
Communicate well in advance with agencies that will be
sending trainees so that management:
Perceives a need for the training
Develops a personal interest in the course and
Expects successful performance from anyone it
sends for training
Continued
8
Appropriate Recruitment
Work with the management to make training selection a
joint process between the trainers and the agency
sending trainees
Make it clear that trainees must apply for a place in the
course and that their applications will be screened
Spell out the criteria for screening and selection
Actually apply the criteria
9
Recruiting Volunteers
Expectations must be:
Realistic in terms of time, other costs, abilities
Developed in concert with:
Populations the volunteers will serve
Professional staff with whom volunteers
will work
Continued
10
Recruiting Volunteers
Communicated clearly to:
Those selecting the volunteer
The volunteers themselves
11
Communities and Agencies: Differing Expectations?
Both want primary
care to reach
grassroots
Agency expects
management of
village drug kit
Villagers expect that volunteer will have opportunity to
improve himself
Conflicts may result
12
Two Aspects of Involvement
In the learning process
Adult learning principles
What I hear, I forget
What I see, I remember
What I do, I understand
Continued
13
Two Aspects of Involvement
In the planning process
The training
committee
Trainee
responsibilities for
their own learning
environment
14
Training Patent Medicine Vendors
Igbo-Ora, a town of
50,000
50 PMV shops
PMVs had trade
association/guild
Opportunities for training
explained at an
association meeting
15
Training Committee
Association appointed a
five-member training
committee to work with the
trainers
Committee polled
members interests
Continued
16
Training Committee
Trainers conducted
survey and shared results
with committee
Committee decided on
curriculum
17
Committee Action
Planned times and
found venue (school)
Printed handout
materials
Set up the venue
each session
Kept attendance,
encouraged participation
Handled review and evaluation
18
Your feedback on this lecture presentation is
very important and will be used for future
revisions. Please take a moment to evaluate
this lecture. The Evaluation link is available
on the lecture page.
Lecture Evaluation
The following table details the grading scheme in this course.
Assignment Value |
Components |
Total Possible Points |
|||
1 – Description of Potential Trainees |
· Characteristics of trainees, job/role description (6 points) · Organization and community description (3 points) · Problem/training need statement (3 points) · Recruitment process explanation (3 points) |
1 5 |
|||
2 – Plan for Diagnosing Training Needs |
· Appropriate information sources (people, documents, etc.) and methods identified ( 10 points) · Findings and priorities (10 points) |
20 |
|||
3 – Sample Training Objectives and Tasks |
· Points are awarded for timely submission of the planning matrices. Feedback will be given for improving the overall training guide. (5 points) |
5 | |||
4 – Training Methods and Resources |
|||||
5 – Evaluation Plan |
· Points are awarded for timely submission of the planning matrices. Feedback will be given for improving the overall training guide. | ||||
Implementation Issues Discussion Forum |
· Points awarded for Posting an issue and commenting on postings of two other people |
||||
Quiz 3 |
· Training follow-up Issues |
10 | |||
6 – Full Training Guide |
· Preparation section (20 points) · Quality of objectives and tasks (10 points) · Appropriateness of methods (10 points) |
100 |
|||
TOTAL |
200 |
1
Assignment # 2: Training Diagnosis Plan and Report Template
Training Topic: Comprehensive Training/Practical Preparation of
Healthcare Workers to Create Awareness and Provision of Efficient
Contraceptive Methods and Services ‐ for Indigenes living in the
Northwestern Communities of Haiti
TRAINING METHODS AND CONTINUING EDUCATION FOR HEALTH WORKERS
Rationale and Overview:
Following the definition of the problem, highlighted by the issue of unintended pregnancies
amongst women of reproductive age (15 to 49 years) in the Northwestern region of Haiti, this
necessitates training and continuing education of health care workers to tackle this problem. The
proposed intervention to address this issue is to train relevant stake holders on the need to
implement feasible and sustainable efficient contraceptive education/services to these
communities. As community participation is integral to the successful outcome of the program,
hence the need for the training to be inclusive of community volunteers, selected by the
indigenes and culturally acceptable to the focus group and the communities at large is
paramount. The utilization of evidence-based scientific literatures to underscore the efficiency of
the proposed contraceptive forms were explored and referenced to support the advocated
training. `
Training Needs Diagnosis Goal:
This includes to:
Assess the knowledge, skills, attitudes and practices of the designated health care
providers(via demonstration and interviews), specifically in the Obstetrics/Gynecology
and General Family Medicine departments, in the provision of contraceptive education
and services, with emphasis on scientifically proven efficient modern contraceptive to
women of reproductive age group in our focus communities.
Evaluate available resources to provide and sustain the proposed health services to the
communities ,the need for collaboration between health care providers and Non-
Governmental Agencies( NGOs) focused on similar goals (in this instance women’s
reproductive health) and to ensure full participation by the communities by incorporating
community nominated volunteer workers into the training/implementation of these
services.
2
Establish priority of the training needs proposed for efficient contraceptive services
which is the focus of the health care providers, community volunteers, etc, who are
involved in this training program.
Instrument Design and Information Sources:
Methods employed to ascertain the needs assessment for the stakeholders were via Observation,
Documentation, and Surveys/Interviews:
Designated Health Care Providers- (Physicians, Midwives/ Nurses, Auxiliary nurses, and
other relevant allied health workers):
Observation of the health personnel during patient contact (following informed consent
from patient) that pertains to contraception education/services.
Documentation review via records of reproductive services regarding contraceptive
education/services
Surveys (via questionnaires) and interviews were administered to evaluate their existing
knowledge base and skills on contraceptive options/services in general and specifically to
evaluate their perception and attitudes towards the implementation of the proposed
efficient forms of contraception services. This was done to customize training
appropriately (either for the development of new skills or for refresher trainings on
current guidelines regarding the use of efficient modern contraception -intra uterine
device(IUD) and hormonal contraceptives (depots and implants)
Head of Port-de-Paix’s Cuban Medical Brigade and the Chief Hospital Administrator:
Question- based surveys and interviews administered to determine their understanding of
the training content and commitment to a successful outcome, by making resources
needed for the implementation/sustenance of the program, as well as willingness for
collaboration with NGOs and community volunteers.
NGO Representative (NGO on women’s health issues):
Interviews and questionnaire administered to determine their understanding of the
training content and commitment to a successful outcome, by making resources needed
for the implementation/sustenance of the program, as well as willingness for
collaboration with NGOs and Community volunteers.
Communities:
Focus group discussions, town hall meetings and outreach programs were scheduled and
implemented to ensure full participation/buy in on the part of the communities most
especially the target population- women of reproductive age 15 to 49 years, to evaluate
the communities perception, their needs and wants regarding the proposed services,
clarify grey areas and gear them to choose their community volunteers.
3
A checklist of resources (including financing, methods of presentation to training committee and
time allocation) to access feasibility and sustenance of program was drafted.
Collection Procedures to obtain Records (aimed at examining current/existing
contraceptive services):
This was achieved by:
Accessing medical records to evaluate documentation pertaining to contraceptive services
in the departments of Obstetrics/Gynecology and General Family Medicine. (Whilst
ensuring patient confidentiality/privacy is protected)
Through Surveys/Interviews; Questionnaires
Observations during patient contacts (following informed consent from patient)
Review of Records obtained pertaining regards to current contraceptive practices /services:
Following the collection of records, they were reviewed, analyzed and the information obtained
used to customize the proposed training program to address the areas of need identified.
Therefore ensuring the program objectives are justified and clear to all stakeholders involved in
the proposed training- including the Health providers, The Chief Hospital Administrator, Head of
Port-de-Paix’s Cuban Medical Brigade, NGO representative and the community leaders/
nominated community workers.
TRAINING DIAGNOSIS PLAN
Audience Information
Needed
Information
Collection Method
Role of Potential
Trainees
Potential trainees
within each
multidisciplinary team
involved (Physicians,
Midwives, Auxiliary
nurses and other
relevant allied health
workers)
To determine the
concerns and issues
surrounding the low
utilization of
contraception,
especially efficient
methods.
Analyze the current
background
knowledge, attitude
and skills related in
the provision of
Surveys/interviews;
Questionnaires
Observations during
patient
contacts(following
informed consent
from patient)
To provide information
requested in real
context for all
collection methods
4
such services.
Identify the
loopholes and
priorities to
emphasize during
training.
Documentation of
contraceptive
services provided in
patient records, still
ensuring
confidentiality
The Chief Hospital
Administrator
To analyze
commitment to
training program, by
provision of support
and resources
needed for
implementation and
collaboration with
other relevant
parties .e.g. NGOs,
etc.
Question based
surveys
Interviews
Provide information
requested
in real context
Head of Port-de-Paix’s
Cuban Medical Brigade
from the Public Sector
To determine the
role of the public
sector input in the
proposed
intervention/training
in terms of
resources, support
and collaborations.
Question based
surveys
Interviews
Provide information
requested in actual
context pertaining to
their role
Communities:
leaders, nominated
volunteers ,focus
population and
community at large
To assess the
knowledge, attitude,
needs and wants of
the communities in
reference to
contraceptive
services.
Focus group
discussion (FGD)
Outreach programs
Personal interviews
Provide information
requested in real
context
Integrated in proposed
training to foster
community
participation/commitme
nt via choosing
community volunteers
to be involved in the
proposed training.
Accessing avenues
designed to address
concerns, questions and
ideas regarding the
proposed services to
5
target training and
improvement.
Records Departments
Obstetrics/Gynecology
and General Family
Departments Clinic
Records
Access medical
records for
documentation
regarding
contraceptive
education and
services
Reviewing patient
records, ensuring
confidentiality is
protected
Training group: health
personnel with access
to records ,will convey
findings to the entire
training group
FINDINGS AND PRIORITIES
Summary of Key Findings:
Training group committed to implement and commence continuing education on
knowledge /skills required for patient counseling and provision of efficient contraceptive
methods, including the recognition of potential adverse effects and scenarios that warrant
referrals to specialist.
Reasons attributed for the inefficient use of the existing contraceptive methods amongst
the focus group included: lack of awareness based on low education levels, poor access to
reproductive services including contraception and lack of finance.
Reasons for not utilizing contraception at all included: beliefs and customs opposed to
using contraception, economic values attached to having children and fear of negative
consequences including perceived sterility.
Reasons for discontinuing contraceptives were mainly attributed to adverse effects, lack
of finance and inconsistent availability of these contraceptives.
The need to provide consistent free and/or subsidized efficient contraception exists in
these communities and this should proceed in a culturally sensitive way to ensure
community buy in/participation and hence the success of the program.
The need to collaborate with NGOs and other health sectors in the community for their
support to advocate and ensure supply of resources needed to sustain proposed
intervention, especially if this would be at no cost or subsidized.
6
It is integral that community nominated volunteers be involved in the training to bridge
any gaps in communication between the communities and health-care workers and give
insightful feedback on how best to serve these communities.
Need to improve community accessibility to services by the provision of clinic stations
within these communities as well.
Priority Training Needs:
To create awareness and build a fundamental knowledge base within these communities
with the help of the community volunteers. Their perception on the quality of service
provided will have a positive impact on utilization and success of the proposed services
Provision of clinic stations within the communities – to improve access to services and
sustenance of contraception use by the recipients.
Provision of free and/ or subsidized contraceptive services to these communities,
removing the obstacle of inadequate finances as a limitation to accessing these services. a
Provision of regular continued education to the designated health care workers to ensure
up-to-date knowledge base, skills, feedbacks and for subsequent training of new recruits.
Effective Monitoring / Surveillance of the utilization of the proposed services (via
community forums, patient interviews, community worker feed backs to evaluate patient/
community satisfaction or complaints, preferred services/type of contraception which will
be beneficial in future planning and for improvement purposes.
Sample Training Need Information Document attached: please see below:
Questionnaire for Health Care Providers (For Physicians and Midwives / Registered
Nurses)
Name: ___________________________________ Date: ___________________
Instructions: Circle the letter(s) for all that apply. (Some questions may have more than one correct
answer.) Follow specific directions for each section.
Multiple Choices
For each of the following questions, circle the letter(s) of the correct answer(s).
1. Which of these are examples of effective nonverbal behaviors?
A. Leaning forward, facing client
7
B. Nodding your head
C. Using short prompting words to make sure the client understands
D. Open and relaxed body posture (arms and legs uncrossed)
E. Using a warm and caring tone of voice
2. What do you say to a client to assure them of confidentiality?
A. That you will not tell anyone else what the client says or tells you
B. That her record will be kept along with other client’s records in the clinic’s record room
C. That only the doctor will see her record.
D. It is best to not discuss it.
3. Which of the following is true of informed choice?
A. It is only necessary if men and women are making a decision about sterilization.
B. It is based on the information given by the provider.
C. Clients need to be able to choose their method from an array of FP options.
D. The provider can make the decision after she has informed the client about the method.
4. For the best outcome for the mother and her infant, how long after birth should she wait before
trying to become pregnant?
A. Any time, as long as she wants to get pregnant
B. Two years
C. Six months
D. Three years
5. Which hormonal FP method might be more challenging for women to use?
A. The Pill (oral contraceptives) because a user has to remember to take a pill every day
B. The IUD because it is inserted by a provider
C. The implant because when it is inserted it is effective for a long time.
D. Sterilization because it is only suitable for women who want no more children.
6. If a client is unsure about which method to use, the provider should
A. Tell the client which method you think is best for her
B. Give her information about all of the methods and tell her to go home and think about it
C. Explore with the client about which method would fit best with her daily life, her present
family life and her goals about having more children
D. Don’t mention any method that you think the client might not be able to use correctly.
7. Which is the best way to counteract a rumor about an FP method?
A. Tell the client that the rumor is very silly.
B. Ignore it because it is just a rumor.
C. Tell the client that people who believe such rumors are stupid.
8
D. Politely explain that the rumor is not true and why it is not true.
8. Which are examples of open‐ended questions?
A. What do you know about the pill?
B. Have you heard about the IUD?
C. What have you heard about the IUD?
D. Do you want to have more children?
True or False
Circle true or false for each statement.
The provider should avoid discussing rumors that the client has
heard.
True False
Clients are more willing to continue using a FP method if they have
been informed about possible side effects.
True False
A good counseling session is one that the provider leads and keeps
control of the discussion.
True False
It is acceptable for the provider to persuade the client to use a
method if it is the best method for her.
True False
Active listening involves both verbal and non‐verbal
communication.
True False
During counseling, you should not discuss the client’s sexual
activity because it is too personal.
True False
A counseling tool is useful because it helps the counselor organize
her thoughts and helps guide decision‐making for the client.
True False
Helping the client to carry out his or her decision is the 4
th
stage in
family planning counseling.
True False
The provider should question the client closely about their
knowledge of and attitudes toward family planning methods.
True False
Couples should not be counseled together because it is best to
counsel them individually.
True False
Fill in the Blank
Fill in the correct answers
Name at least 3 of the 4 questions you should ask to identify methods suited to your client’s
needs and goals. a) b) c) ______________
TrainingMethods and Continuing Education 1
SAMPLE TRAINING DIAGNOSIS PLAN
Practical Preparation of Waterless Alcohol Hand Rub,
Sharps Containers and Personal Protective Equipment (PPE)
From Locally Available Supplies
In Addis Ababa, Ethiopia
1. BACKGROUND (FROM ASSIGNMENT 1)
Hospital and Community Setting: Employees are working in a medium size government
hospital located in the center of the capital city Addis Ababa, Ethiopia. The majority of the
patients served in the hospital are homeless or impoverished inner city clientele with high rates
of HIV, STIs and TB as well as other infectious diseases. Around 275-300 patients are seen in
the hospital every day, and there are 175 beds. The hospital has a limited budget dictated by the
regional health bureau, and often lacks basic items such as gloves and syringes. There is a very
poor drainage system in the hospital, with non-functioning sinks and toilets in patient and doctor
areas with no running water and sporadic electricity.
Training Issue: Nosocomial infection rates are very high, and patients often have to extend their
stay due to hospital acquired infections. This is costly for the patient with purchasing meds and
hospital costs. It is also harmful to the health of all patients, in particular for those immuno-
compromised. Among the healthcare workers, there is no standardized hand washing practice,
compounded by the non-functioning plumbing system of the hospital. In addition, there is a very
high rate of needles pricks in healthcare workers from used patient needles. The cleaning staff
are regularly out of work due to sickness, and rarely use protective equipment while working in
the wards.
Participants: Proposed 25 trainees for the first round; The Training organizer (head of
Infection Prevention Committee) shall discuss with the Medical Director regarding the
recruitment and selection of the participants from the hospital. A formal request for training
participation will be sent.
6 Nurses (1 from each major department of the of the hospital – Obstetrics, Gynecology,
Surgery, Internal medicine, Pediatrics, and outpatient departments) –
Educational level: Diploma or Degree in nursing; majority are women. They spend a
significant time with patients, and are susceptible to needle pricks and causing
nosocomial infections.
10 Health Assistants (Nurse Assistant level – From each of the departments listed above) –
Educational level: high school; mixed gender. The health assistants have the most contact
with the patient, are susceptible to needle pricks and can also easily cause nosocomial
infections such as with catheters, or without hand washing. They could be in charge of
preparing the handrub for nurses and doctors, in addition preparing sharps containers and
PPE.
2 Central Supply workers – Educational level: University degree. They manage
purchasing the supplies in the hospital. They can be an integral part in collecting
Training Methods and Continuing Education 2
materials from the hospital and transforming them into sharps containers and PPE. Also,
lobbying for the purchse of glycerine and alcohol for the handrub.
1 Sanitarian (Environmental Health specialist) – Educational level: University degree.
This person is in charge of the overall waste management and infection control of the
hospital. They can manage and supervise the sharps disposal and use of PPE in the
cleaning staff.
4 Cleaners: Educational level: basic reading and writing skills. They currently are
responsible for collecting sharps and dealing with medical waste. They will also help in
preparation of PPE.
1 Administrator – Educational level: University degree. This person is in charge of
making financial and administrative decisions of the hospital through communication
with the Medical Director regarding budget, procurement etc.
1 Regional Health Bureau Representative – This person will be critical to the
sustainability of the initiative and can influence other government hospitals in the country
to start creating these materials.
2. RATIONALE AND OVERVIEW
Training Needs Diagnosis Goal: To determine the current attitudes, knowledge and practice of
hand washing and use of personal protective equipment among health staff, as well as the
commitment of the decision makers of the hospital to Infection Prevention. To assess the
availability of supplies to be used for PPE and hand rub preparation. To assess the amount of
knowledge retained by potential trainees, who, in the past, have received some sort of IP
knowledge update.
Instrument Design: Several instruments were used in this needs assessment:
• Questionnaire for health workers trained in IP in all target departments on retained
knowledge of basic infection prevention practices
• List of questions for the health workers; questions for medical director and administrative
manager; and questions for the group analysis with the Infection Prevention Committee
(IPC).
• Checklist of materials needed for preparing alcohol hand rub and PPE from locally made
supplies
Information Collection Procedures: The Medical Director of the hospital was consulted and
gave approval for the assessment. The IPC was also consulted and a member co-led the
assessment to ensure ownership of the findings. The IPC formed the basis of a Training
Committee as its members represented different types of staff and departments. Additional
people were co-opted to round out representation. The instruments were developed with the IPC.
Members of the committee divided the tasks to shorten time of collection and work-load burden.
Information Processing and Analysis: The findings were reviewed by the Medical Director,
head of the IPC and the trainers. The information is under analysis with the IPC.
Training Methods and Continuing Education 3
3. TRAINING DIAGNOSIS PLAN
Audience Information Needed Information
Collection Method
Role of Potential
Trainees
Potential
trainees in
each
profession
Current attitude and
practice regarding hand
washing and use of PPE.
To collect concerns,
questions and ideas about
these issues and the
upcoming training (i.e.,
what do participants feel
they need to learn)
Interviews using a
questionnaire geared
towards each
profession
Training Committee
involved in
questionnaire design
and reviews for
content validity
Potential
Trainees in
each
profession
The current knowledge
level of the previously
trained staff on basic IP
practices
Questionnaire
As above
Medical
Director and
Administrative
Manager
To assess the commitment
of both to providing extra
supplies, support and
incentives for the new IP
campaign
Interview with
prewritten questions
Training Committee
helps pose questions
for management
Infection
Prevention
Committee
(IPC)
To determine what the
current action plan for the
committee is, to identify
necessary trainings. To
involve the committee in
the assessment and training
for ownership.
Preliminary Group
Discussion Analysis
Training Committee
meets with IPC
Infection
Prevention
Committee
To review past activities of
the IP committee and
review future plans,
problem solving
techniques, etc.
Review meeting
minutes of IP
committee
Training Committee
discusses critical
incidents reported in
minutes
Central
Supply Staff
To assess the availability
of materials to make PPE,
hand rub, and sharps
containers.
Observation and
interview using a
checklist of necessary
vs. actual
Training Committee
discusses results of
observations (Note
observations by co-
workers may be
awkward, hence
trainers observe)
Training Methods and Continuing Education 4
Audience Information Needed Information
Collection Method
Role of Potential
Trainees
Health Staff in
all targeted
wards
To observe the current
practice of hand washing
and disposal of sharps and
use of PPE. To assess the
current attitude regarding
job tasks and interaction
with patients.
Observation As above
Records
Department
To find if records on
Healthcare worker needle
sticks are available and
documented
Reviewing Employee
Health Records
Training Committee
participation depends
on confidentiality
issues; trainers may
summarize relevant
issues to present to
Training Committee
Records
Department
To analyze the absenteeism
of health workers due to
illness, see if there is
correlation with profession
Reviewing Employee
absenteeism records
As above
Records
Department
To assess whether records
of nosocomial infections
are present, or records of
outbreaks of infections in
wards
Reviewing patient
records, and hospital
records about
nosocomial infections,
review of hospital
based surveys and
studies on nosocomial
infections.
Training Committee
members who have
permission to access
files and records may
summarize these for
the group after
observing appropriate
confidentiality
4. FINDINGS AND PRIORITIES
Key Findings:
• There is no formal needle stick reporting system, but heard from word of mouth that
surgery is more of a problem than others.
• There are no records or surveys of patient hospital acquired infections
• Alcohol is readily available, but glycerin must be purchased for the hand rub. Most
supplies for making PPE will have to be purchased outside the hospital. Sharps containers
can be found in the hospital.
• The Medical Director, Admin manager and Central supply staff are enthusiastic about IP
and are ready to contribute to the sustainability of the program through purchasing,
allocating budget (small but something), and incentives for healthcare workers for the
future. Glycerin can only be bought limitedly, so need for improving access to water for
staff other than doctors.
• The IP committee was planning on having a refresher course for its staff on IP, but was
unsure of how to increase hand washing, proper disposal of sharps and where to acquire
Training Methods and Continuing Education 5
PPE. IP committee also wants to use the training opportunity to get feedback from staff
about the trainings and what they see best for the future (create evaluation forms and
suggestion forms, involve staff more in IP committee meetings)
• Cleaners are frequently out sick, more than any other profession
• Staff has a relatively low retention of the basic Infection Prevention practices, and need a
brief knowledge update. They also requested that they want a mechanism to provide input
for future IP activities, such as a suggestion box.
• Staff are enthusiastic about their work, and are ready to learn, improve and be creative.
There is strong leadership in the hospital, and there are motivational signs around the
hospital promoting infection prevention. There is a strong desire to improve IP practices
in the hospital as this hospital is a model site for IP. They have ideas about fixing jugs
with taps in each room due to no running water.
Priority Training Needs:
• Brief IP knowledge update needed for staff (At beginning of the course)
• Need to train staff how to document needle-sticks and nosocomial
documentation/reporting while a formal system is put into place.
• Different needs for different professions, suggestion to break up training in afternoon into
profession groups to learn what is most relevant to their work. These sessions to be taught
by the IP committee staff for ownership.
• Creation of water jugs with taps to be included as part of the training (in addition to hand
rub)
Instructions for Critique & Analysis
The class will watch seven video cases that raise issues/offer insight about the process of marketing within diverse organizations. Your role is to identify the issue being discussed, apply concepts from class during that chapter being read in the textbook and analyze to identify the lessons possible to learn from what you observe, and to connect these to your own experiences.
DO NOT DESCRIBE WHAT IS GOING ON THE VIDEO. Your response to the questions posed and the comments you make will be incorporated in your contribution to class discussion.
Please prepare a 1.5-2 page double spaced critique of each video found in each Week’s Assignment folder. Analyze the main points from the video and how it relates to the following:
· Concepts in the respective reading and classroom discussion
· Your personal and professional understanding of marketing, advertising and sales concepts
Components |
Descriptions |
1. Organization and community description/context |
The trainees will be based in Vietnam northern province of Ha Noi. It will be facilitated and provided by G-Link. The G-Link is a community-based organization that was established by Lê Minh Thành, a trained community health worker (Glink Ha Noi, 2019). The main objective for this training event is to provide and improve HIV/AIDS testing services in close proximity to the community, especially in most vulnerable segments. This training event will cover communication skills and counseling, which are critical in enhancing the awareness creation and testing of HIV/AIDS. Background Information: Vietnam is a country that has, for a long time, been classified as a developing country. However, it has experienced healthcare problems as it has been transitioning to one of the fastest-growing economies. The country has a population of about 97 million, and 8.4% of the population lives below the poverty line (Diem & Van Hoang, 2018). Program for Appropriate Technology in Health (PATH) in Vietnam, in association with the government, are advocating for HIV lay testing and self-testing as a way of reducing HIV new infections. Residents in the rural provinces in northern Vietnam, especially the LGBT+ community, are stigmatized and hence often shy away from seeking HIV testing services from the health facilities. These residents are vulnerable to HIV/AIDS due to risky sexual behaviors, including unprotected sex and illicit drug use. The silence by the LGBT+ community in rural areas has exposed many to the risk of HIV/AIDS as there is little knowledge on the prevention and management of the disease. |
2. Problem/training need statement |
Communities living in areas with few HIV testing centers are faced with challenges, especially of lacking the necessary care when HIV positive. This is especially when the issues cannot be openly talked about due to the cultural challenges. This leaves many people exposed to the risk of infection due to ignorance (Bui et al., 2018). Community Health Workers (CHWs) and Social Workers (SWs) provide essential services directly to the communities where hospitals and health facilities are not able to reach. Therefore, this training program aims targeting up to ten teams (consisting of 2-3 members/team) of CHWs/CWs, which will be based in the northern province of Ha Noi for awareness creation, testing, preventive measures and control of HIV/AIDS. The trainees will be educated on the proper testing methods to be utilized as well as counseling residents living with HIV/AIDS. The training event will also focus on the prevention of new infections through establishment of proper preventive measures, i.e. efforts to ensure those who are involved in high risk sexual behaviors use HIV Pre-Exposure Prophylaxis (PrEP) pills. After the successful completion of training, trainees will be encouraged with initiatives to create awareness, reduce stigmatization and support people living with HIV/AIDS and the preventive strategies that can be applied at the community level, since every individual in these communities is considered highly vulnerable to the disease. |
3. Characteristics of trainees, job/role description |
Role#1: Community health workers (4 per team) total: 40 positions Description: community health workers are an integral part of the project. They will be responsible for referring community members to the testing stations. This requires that they should be able to coordinate and manage the flow of people as well as assisting individuals in finding relevant information. They should also have a good understanding of the initiative and the local language so that they answer the questions of people as they wait for testing. Apart from this, they are required to provide appointments and referrals. They should also be able to carry out HIV lay testing and educating people on self-testing Desired Characteristics: A person with excellent communication skills, polite, friendly, prepared to work in a team, and flexible in their schedule. Eligible: Males and females with college diplomas Role #2: Social Workers (5 in a team) Total: 50 positions Description: The social workers will be involved in teaching the communities about HIV/AIDS, prevention measures, and management. They will also be involved in counseling, especially those who have tested HIV positive. Desired characteristics: An individual with good communication skills, patience, charming, focused, ability to work in a team and respect for the coworkers. Eligibility: Male and females with a bachelor’s degree or diploma in social work. Role #3: Province Administrator (1 position) Description: this is the person who will be responsible for coordinating all the activities in the province. This includes ensuring the supplies are delivered to all the ten villages; provide feedback to the Glink and weekly data. Desired Characteristics: a good team leader, motivator, excellent communication skills, proper planning, and organization skills. Eligibility: A male or female with experience in leadership and a degree in business administration. |
4. Recruitment process explanation |
The applicants will be sought through direct applications or volunteer applications in G-Link. The communication on successful applicants who qualify for interviews will be made directly using emails and phone numbers. All the applicants must be willing to work in the northern province for one year. The applicants for role #3 must be critical thinkers and ethical decision-makers, and this must be demonstrated during the interview. |
(Any other relevant information) |
References
Bui, Q. T. T., Brickley, D. B., & Hills, N. K. (2018). Home-based care and perceived quality of life among people living with HIV in Ho Chi Minh City, Viet Nam. AIDS and Behavior, 22(1), 85-91.
Diem, H. X., & Van Hoang, T. (2018). Multidimensional poverty in Viet Nam: Evidence from a rural household survey (No. 2018/127). WIDER Working Paper.
G-Link (2019). Home/Services. Retrieved from
https://www.glinkvn.com/en/about-us/
on 01/22/2020
Name(s):
Training Topic: Cushing’s Disease Clinical Trial Nurse Coordinator Training
1
Training Diagnosis Plan and Report Template
Instructions: If more than one person is working as a group on this assignment, ensure all names appear at the top of this paper. In
Step 1 add as many rows as needed for your particular setting. Note that you may not be able to gather all information you list in Step
1 prior to submitting this assignment. Even so, please list all the information you ideally would like to collect. Mention any gaps in
Step 2 and indicate if and when such information might be available. If there are such gaps, Step 3 may be a best guess scenario for
now, and of course it can be revised if more information comes in before you finish your training guide. If you are not physically
present in the location for which the training is designed, you may need to rely on e-mails, Skype calls, documents from the internet
and of course your own experiences for information on training needs.
1. Plan for Gathering Training Need Information
Audience (e.g. potential trainees,
supervisors, community members,
the agency staff)
Information Needed Information Collection
Method (e.g. interview, pre-test,
document review, observation
checklist, record review, FGD)*
Role of Potential Trainees
(e.g. Training Committee helps
design instrument, moderates focus
groups)
Endocrinology Clinical Trial
Nurse Coordinators
Existing understanding of the
approach /steps required in
recruiting, screening, enrolling
and communicating the details
of a research protocol to
patients with Cushing’s
disease
Advisory Board of clinical
trial nurse coordinators,
patients, patient advocates
Training Committee helps to
develop the advisor board
discussion guide and related
questions
Endocrinology Clinical Trial
Nurse Coordinators
Current understanding of the
psychosocial symptoms and
factors that affect patients with
Cushing’s disease, which may
potentially impact patient
participation in a clinical trial
Pre- and post-tests to identify
and directly measure
learning/practice gaps and
compare outcomes between
the pre- and post-training
settings
Training Committee helps to
craft the questions and also
evaluates/compares the pre- vs
post-test findings
Name(s):
Training Topic: Cushing’s Disease Clinical Trial Nurse Coordinator Training
2
Endocrinology Clinical Trial
Nurse Coordinators
Ability to administer a Quality
of Life/Patient Reported
Outcomes survey to patients
as part of the research
protocol, without introducing
bias
Observation of the trial
coordinators administering the
questionnaires to patients
Trainers conduct the
observation, review and
discuss observation findings
and provide feedback directly
to the trial coordinators for
improvement
Endocrinology Clinical Trial
Nurse Coordinators
Utilization of a nurse-to-
patient checklist to 1) assess
patient’s potential
participation/eligibility in the
research protocol and 2) to
facilitate communication
between trial coordinators and
patients
Observation of the trial
coordinators’ utilization of the
checklist; interviews of the
coordinators with prewritten
questions related to ease-of-
use of the checklist
Training committee helps to
design the checklist and
follow-up interview questions.
Trainers conduct the actual
observation, review and
discuss observation findings
and provide feedback to the
trial coordinators for
improvement
Institutional Review Board
(IRB)
Approval of the IRB must be
sought for all materials related
to the research protocol and
related training
Group Discussion Training Committee must
meet with the IRB and discuss
all aspects of the training; all
materials related to the
protocol (e.g. checklists,
Quality of Life questionnaires)
and to the training should be
submitted to the IRB for
review and approval
Trial Investigators To assess understanding of the
obligations required and
overall support of the trial
investigators who are
ultimately responsible and
accountable for every aspect
of the research protocol
Interviews Training Committee meets
with Trial Investigators to
outline/review/discuss the
training plan of action
Name(s):
Training Topic: Cushing’s Disease Clinical Trial Nurse Coordinator Training
3
*If needed, describe additional details on instrument design, information collection procedures, information processing, information
analysis, etc., here
2. Summary of Key Findings (Mention what information is available to date such as from documents or surveys and say what
will be collected later)
According to the findings of a recent advisory board conducted in June 2013, trial coordinators identified significant challenges to face
when conducting a research protocol in Cushing’s disease that need to be addressed. Particular gaps included:
Challenges in Cushing’s disease patients’ psychosocial symptoms impacting their potential trial participation
Complicated trial visit schedules require clear explanation to patients
See attached page 4 for additional findings from the advisory board.
Additional data to be collected at a later date (TBD)
3. List of Priority Training Needs (You may need to make assumptions for now based on limited available information and
update as you go along)
Need to train the trial coordinators on the psychosocial symptoms that may impact patients’ emotional status, eligibility and
overall participation in a clinical trial
Need to train the nurse coordinators on how they approach and communication with patients at the recruitment, screening,
enrollment and monitoring stages of the research protocol in a health literate, patient friendly method (e.g., clearly explain
what is placebo, what is randomization, etc)
Creation of a nurse-to-patient checklist, along with a calendar template to more clearly describe to the patient expectations and
time commitment required
4. Attach sample training needs information collection instruments Note: see page 5 for sample of data collection instrument
Name(s):
Training Topic: Cushing’s Disease Clinical Trial Nurse Coordinator Training
4
Note to Advisors of Cushing’s Disease Clinical Trial Advisory Board
The feedback provided at the June 2013 by patients, patient advocates, caregivers and research nurses on trials involving
patients with Cushing’s disease was greatly appreciated. The advice provided important insight for the clinical development
team as they move forward with administering the protocol.
Key takeaway points for the clinical team included but were not limited to:
Developing a “doable” visit schedule for patients with Cushing’s disease.
o The clinical team is following up to evaluate the time to receive Urine Free Cortisol results from the central lab.
Consideration of allowing a “window” around visit dates in the protocol.
Consideration for the transportation / travel issues for patients with Cushing’s disease.
Consideration of the time commitment involved by the patient for follow up.
Consideration of the challenges for completing QoL questionnaires when the patient’s focus and attention is challenged
o We have already investigated the possibility of providing a verbal format for QoL questionnaires, but this will
not be possible as the tool is validated in written format only.
Need to develop patient/caregiver materials related to the trial including:
Checklist for research nurses
Calendar template clearly describing the patient expectations
Dear Colleague letter (incl. postage if possible) for the investigator to use to let referring physicians know of the trial
Need to develop patient / caregiver educational materials describing clinical trials
Name(s):
Training Topic: Cushing’s Disease Clinical Trial Nurse Coordinator Training
5
Sample Discussion Guide Instrument
What expectation do you have, or what is most important, when considering enrolling a patient with Cushing’s disease
in a clinical trial?
Are there any best practices to share regarding tips and talking points for patients considering taking part in a trial?
Does the reason for conducting the study make sense from a patient’s perspective?
Do you have any concerns about the treatment plans and arms?
What could potentially be an obstacle for patients to stay on the trial until study end?
What might be a patient or advocate’s concerns prior to study entry?
What is the most important aspect that a patient might consider to enroll in the study?
What can we include in the informed consent to better explain the trial to participants?
Any other suggestions to improve understanding of the trial by potential patients?
Do you have suggestions on making the visit assessment more patient-friendly?
Do you foresee any issues with the visit schedule for patients? If yes, please elaborate
Do you believe the visit schedule will be easy to follow for patients? If no, about which visits and/or assessments do you
have concerns?
Name(s):
Training Topic:
Training Diagnosis Plan and Report Template
Instructions: If more than one person is working as a group on this assignment, ensure all names appear at the top of this paper. In Step
1
add as many rows as needed for your particular setting. Note that you may not be able to gather all information you list in Step 1 prior to submitting this assignment. Even so, please list all the information you ideally would like to collect. Mention any gaps in Step 2 and indicate if and when such information might be available. If there are such gaps, Step 3 may be a best guess scenario for now, and of course it can be revised if more information comes in before you finish your training guide. If you are not physically present in the location for which the training is designed, you may need to rely on e-mails, Skype calls, documents from the internet and of course your own experiences for information on training needs.
1. Plan for Gathering Training Need Information
Audience (e.g. potential trainees, supervisors, community members, the agency staff) |
Information Needed |
Information Collection Method (e.g. interview, pre-test, document review, observation checklist, record review, FGD)* |
Role of Potential Trainees (e.g. Training Committee helps design instrument, moderates focus groups) |
*If needed, describe additional details on instrument design, information collection procedures, information processing, information analysis, etc., here (
2. Summary of Key Findings (Mention what information is available to date such as from documents or surveys and say what will be collected later)
3. List of Priority Training Needs (You may need to make assumptions for now based on limited available information and update as you go along)
4. Attach sample training needs information collection instruments
PAGE
1
DiagnosingTraining Needs
William Brieger, MPH, CHES, DrPH
Johns Hopkins University
Section A
What Information Is Needed?
The material in this video is subject to the copyright of the owners of the material and is being provided for educational purposes under
rules of fair use for registered students in this course only. No additional copies of the copyrighted work may be made or distributed.
3
Diagnostic Questions
What tasks do the workers have to do (job description)?
Have their tasks changed recently?
Are the workers actually practicing their assigned tasks?
What do the workers already know about their tasks?
4
More Questions
What skills do they already possess?
Where do the workers need extra help and input to
perform their tasks?
What tasks are workers unable to perform because they
do not know what to do or do not have the necessary
skills?
What are the workers’ attitudes toward their assigned
tasks?
Continued
5
More Questions
What is the ideal (standard) way that workers’ tasks
should be performed?
What do clients expect from the workers; are they able to
perform to clients’ expectations?
Answers to these questions form a baseline from which
the outcome of training can be evaluated
6
Understanding Tasks
Think about the work that will
actually be done by the
trainees when they return to
work after training
Improve the list by reviewing
existing curricula, job
descriptions, and technical
literature
Discuss their tasks with
potential trainees
Continued
7
Understanding Tasks
Improve the list by comparing it with what the
community needs and the local culture
Seek community input on these needs and on their
views of health worker performance
Improve the list by observing what health workers
actually are doing on the job and by talking with them
about their work
8
Prepare Oral Rehydration Solution (ORS)
Prepare ORS
solution
Assess presence of
signs of
dehydration
Ask mother/care-
giver about the
child’s condition
Continued
9
Prepare Oral Rehydration Solution (ORS)
Determine extent
of dehydration
Develop appropriate
treatment plan
Treat patient
according to plan
Refer cases of severe
dehydration to hospital
Continued
10
Prepare Oral Rehydration Solution (ORS)
Treat or refer for
other problems,
Record data of
patient in register
Compile data on
monthly basis;
submit report
11
Analyzing Tasks as a Basis of Training
Examine the task carefully in the context in which it is
expected to be performed
Sub-divide the task into various components: sub-tasks,
competencies, or steps
Decide what skills are needed to perform each task and
step
Decide what knowledge and attitudes are needed to
carry out each task and step
1
2
Task Analysis #9: Record Patient Data in Register
Context
! During provision of
diarrhea management
services
Components
! Writing on forms and
in register vital
information on patient
and response
Continued
13
Task Analysis #9: Record Patient Data in Register
Skills
! Writing, spelling, calculation …
Knowledge
! Specific information required on forms
Attitudes
! Appreciate importance of data recording
14
A Reminder: Trainee Involvement
Task analysis should
not be an external
or detached
exercise
Continued
15
A Reminder: Trainee Involvement
The training committee can discuss
! The tasks involved in their work
! And those areas needing updating
Trainee discussion groups can highlight concerns
Section B
Documents and Interviews
The material in this video is subject to the copyright of the owners of the material and is being provided for educational purposes under
rules of fair use for registered students in this course only. No additional copies of the copyrighted work may be made or distributed.
2
Information Needs: Who and How
!”#
“#!
$%&'())*
+&(&,)%*-
./)01,)(23
45′)(.*-
46778(‘.3
96287)(.* !”#$%&’
($)
*”‘+%,#&,$-.
/,-0&”‘.1″&+2
3″4’#5#”%’.
+$//,&&””‘
#:*)%;&.’6(
6$%7
#”%8$%/5-+”
95+,:,&;
5”””/”-&
<5##,-=. >“5:&>1)”>5?,$%
<(.)%;')= @0"'&,$--5,%"'. #%"&"'&'.19AB'
C-D*”#&>
,-&”%?,”4′
E0%?”;.19AB’
3
Examples of Documents
Job descriptions and performance standards
Progress reports: monthly, quarterly, annual
Minutes of sta! meetings
Professional literature
Organizational policies
Files and records on events
! Complaints, grievances, accidents
! Absenteeism, sickness, turnover
4
The Job Description as a Basis for Training
How do people view job descriptions?
! A limitation to my freedom
! A source of argument with my supervisors
! A guide to how I fit into the organization
! A useful structure so I know what to do, where and
when
Thus, a job description can be an asset or a liability
depending on how it is used by management
5
What Are Job Descriptions?
An attempt to define clearly and without ambiguity the
duties and responsibilities of each job
A word picture of the:
! Duties
! Responsibilities and
! Organizational relationships
! That constitute a given position in the organization
Continued
6
What Are Job Descriptions?
An outline of continuing work assignments and scope
of responsibility that are su”ciently di!erent to warrant
unique job title.
An up-to-date explanation of current work requirements
Detailed information on special knowledge and
resources needed to perform the work
7
Diagnosing Training Needs Based on Job Description
Have duties and responsibilities changed?
Is the employee performing duties and responsibilities as
well as before?
Have new organizational structures and relationships
been introduced?
8
Job Descriptions for Diagnosis
Has professional
practice changed
such that job
descriptions are no
longer current?
Are new knowledge,
resources, and skills
needed to perform
the job?
9
Plans and Progress Reports
What do plans and reports contain?
! Activities? outcomes? goals?
What targets have been met, or not?
What activities worked, and which were less successful?
10
Reviewing Plans and Reports
Do reports over
time indicate trends
in successes,
problems, results?
What training needs
can be discerned?
11
Minutes of Meetings
Are sta! meetings actually held? (Who attends?)
Are meetings used for problem identification and
solving?
Are meetings used for continuing education?
Are issues identified during meetings that require more
formal IST sessions?
! Technical/service issues
! Policy/procedures issues
! Human relations/communication issues
12
Professional Literature
Updates practices and new approaches that health
workers require to be e!ective
13
Changes in Policy: E.g., Malaria Case Management
Resistance
developing for
chloroquine
SP is second
line—but
resistance is
developing
Continued
14
Changes in Policy: E.g., Malaria Case Management
Drug policies change
Prepackaged drugs help reduce resistance
But health workers need to learn how to use new, third
generation drugs
15
Files and Records on Events
Records of events like accidents, absences, and
complaints tells us directly and indirectly something
about workers’ performance
Frequent absences may reflect
! Stress related to inability to perform tasks
! Boredom with tasks assigned
Accidents may indicate skill levels in handling equipment
16
Feedback from Stakeholders
Feedback = interviews
Stakeholders in the training process are many
! Workers/potential trainees
! Supervisors and managers
! Clients/community members
! Professional bodies/associations
Stakeholders can not only provide information about
training needs but should also be involved in collecting
and analyzing that information
17
Interviews in Context
Documents report past actions or planned intentions of
an organization or individual
Observations show the behavior of the employee and
the environment in which she works
Interviews obtain the direct input of the employee and
other stakeholders
! For example, their knowledge, attitudes, opinions,
values, perceptions
18
Interviewing May Include
In-depth, open-ended interviews with employees,
employers, and clients
Questionnaire: structured format to obtain opinions of
employees
Tests: specific questions on job knowledge and skills
Continued
19
Interviewing May Include
Focus group discussions among employees and clients
Group problem analysis: specific discussions among
employees around a work site issue that needs to be
addressed
20
Other Ways to Get Input
Suggestion boxes
Brainstorming during
sta! meetings
Informal conversations
during breaks, lunch,
water cooler
Role play of
challenging situations
21
Interviews Can Take Place in the Community
Focus groups provide an
opportunity for feedback
on health worker
! Performance
! Attitudes
! Timeliness
! Communication
of information
Section C
Observation of Performance
The material in this video is subject to the copyright of the owners of the material and is being provided for educational purposes under
rules of fair use for registered students in this course only. No additional copies of the copyrighted work may be made or distributed.
2
Observation
The best way to judge trainee skills and relationships is
to observe them on the job
This can be done in a formal, structured way
! For example, through the use of checklists
Or, observation can be informal
! Integrated into normal supervision
3
Observation Can Look For …
How employees perform tasks (using a checklist to
compare with standard
The flow of service
The interaction between employees and clients
Availability of supplies, equipment, etc., that are needed
for employees to perform required tasks
4
Facility Needs Assessment
CDC, under a USAID project
called African Child Survival
Initiative, developed
continuing education
units (CEUs) in many State
Ministries of Health in
Nigeria
Continued
5
Facility Needs Assessment
CEUs were responsible for training local government
health sta! in basic child survival programming skills
! Immunization
! Oral rehydration
! Maintaining good records
Continued
6
Facility Needs Assessment
Although training
modules on these
topics were available
from WHO, UNICEF
and the Federal
Ministry of Health
The CEUs were
encouraged first to find out what was happening on the
ground before inviting participants for training
Continued
7
Facility Needs Assessment
Using the checklist, CEU sta! observed
! Sta! at work
! Availability of clinics supplies and materials
! Flow of patients among other factors
They also interviewed clients to determine what they
had gained from their clinic visits
A sample of the items from the checklist are found in the
course notes
8
Facility Needs Checklist
9
Observers and the Observed
Observations may have
limitations
The person being observed
may not behave “normally”
The observer must establish
trust and blend into the
background
10
Triangulate Multiple Methods
Clearly more than one diagnostic method should be
used to determine training needs and understand the
solutions required
Example: polio eradication e!orts
! Records show that an increasing number of
children were receiving immunizations during
state-wide campaigns but
! Reports from federal sentinel surveillance sites
identify new cases of wild polio virus
11
Legend
Wild Poliovirus type 1 (75)
Wild Poliovirus type 3 (7)
Nigeria: Distribution of Wild poliovirus by type Jan July, 2002
NIE/EPI 16-Dec-03
Maps Are Documents
12
More Records, Documents
Reports show numbers of children vaccinated during
house-to-house exercises approaching targets
But projected census data from the state indicate that
these targets may be only 80% of the likely population of
children
A newspaper article during the last campaign has a letter
complaining about government e!orts to “sterilize our
children” with vaccines
13
Village Where Wild Virus Found
High coverage reported
Discussions were held
with elders
Fear was expressed
about sterilization
Note was made of male vaccinators, while women hid in
houses with children
One elder showed discarded vials of vaccine in the bush
outside the village
14
Health Worker Views
Informal interviews were
held with health workers
where they said:
! Political pressure to
report good numbers
at any cost is strong
! Village beliefs and customs are an impediment to
child health
! There is no reason to question accuracy of target
goals (numbers of eligible children)
15
Observations
Finally, trainers followed some vaccinators into the field
during the next campaign
When they approached a village, some people ran and
hid in their huts
The vaccinators ordered the locally selected “guides’”
around like servants
No visits were made to the house of the chief
16
Implications for Training
Need for human relations and cultural respect
Skills in estimating village populations or conducting a
local census
Communication skills to better explain vaccines to
community members
Information on sentinel surveillance process and
implications of wild virus
A Rapid Training Needs Assessment
Peter Johnson, CNM, PhD, FACNM
Section D
The material in this video is subject to the copyright of the owners of the material and is being provided for educational purposes under
rules of fair use for registered students in this course only. No additional copies of the copyrighted work may be made or distributed.
2
Education, Training and Curriculum Development
Source: http://www.jhpiego.org/
http://www.jhpiego.org/
3
Capacity Project
A global initiative funded by USAID
Improved workforce planning and leadership
Developing better education and training programs for
the workforce
Strengthening systems to support workforce
performance
4
Developed for CHART
Caribbean HIV/AIDS regional training network
Increase access to HIV/AIDS prevention, care, and
treatment through a robust and sustainable training
network
National training centers located in Jamaica, Bahamas,
Haiti (2), and Barbados
Relationship with OECS
5
CHART Request
Assess knowledge, skills, and attitudes related to
selected HIV/AIDS related competencies
Assess institutional and socio-cultural factors a!ecting
HIV/AIDS care
Analyze relationship between human (training related)
and environmental (non-training related) factors
a!ecting HIV/AIDS care
Assess factors a!ecting communication/collaboration
patterns within teams responsible for HIV/AIDS care
6
Project Work Plan
Prioritize competencies to be measured (October–
November 07)
Develop methodology including instruments and data
collection forms (December 07–February 08)
Facilitators workshop: Kingston, Jamaica (March 08)
Mentored RNAs: Jamaica (April 08)
Mentored RNAs: Eastern Caribbean (May 08)
Mentored RNAs: Bahamas (June 08)
Present initial RNA findings to CHART (July 08)
7
Preparing Facilitators
25 trainers attended an orientation workshop in
Kingston, Jamaica
RNA process builds on existing trainer proficiency
Mentored RNA experience
8
Strengths and Weaknesses
Strength Weakness
Observation
Record what is actually
happening
Obtrusive;
Subjective
Survey
Gather lots of objective
information;
Easy to analyze
Timely;
Expensive;
Poor response
Focus Group
Familiar to workers;
Brainstorming e!ect
Subjective;
Influence of leaders on
response
Workshop
Familiar;
Brainstorming;
Stakeholder buy in
Expensive
Traditional Needs Assessment
9
Strengths and Weaknesses
Strength Weakness
Observation
Record what is actually
happening
Obtrusive;
Subjective
Survey
Gather lots of objective
information;
Easy to analyze
Timely;
Expensive;
Poor response
Focus Group
Familiar to workers;
Brainstorming e!ect
Subjective;
Influence of leaders on
response
Workshop
Familiar;
Brainstorming;
Stakeholder buy in
Expensive
Traditional Needs Assessment
10
CHART Rapid Training Needs Assessment
Builds on traditional needs assessment strengths
Attempts to overcome traditional weaknesses
Contains interactive and individual responses
Provides immediate feedback to participating workers
11
RNA Methodology
Focuses on an area of service delivery
Task analysis using importance: performance measures
Competency-based assessment of knowledge, skills, and
attitudes
Small mixed group of appropriate participants
Conducted within community
12
Key stakeholder orientation
Observation
Importance-performance
Assessment
Interactive
Survey
Focus group
Interactive
Competency-assessment
Group analysis with
participants
Survey
Focus group
RNA Process
13
Importance:
Performance Survey
Individual and confidential
Short: less than 10 minute process
! How IMPORTANT do YOU believe each task is to
achieving optimal client outcome?
! How WELL do you believe that YOU PERFORM
each task?
14
Workshop ID _________________ RNA Location ____________
Task
Importance
LOW HIGH
Provides clear and accurate
information to client during
pretest counseling
1 2 3 4 5 6 7
Maintains confidentiality
throughout counseling and
testing process
1 2 3 4 5 6 7
Obtains informed consent from
client
1 2 3 4 5 6 7
Importance Survey
15
Workshop ID _________________ RNA Location ____________
Task
Performance
LOW HIGH
Provides clear and accurate
information to client during
pretest counseling
1 2 3 4 5 6 7
Maintains confidentiality
throughout counseling and
testing process
1 2 3 4 5 6 7
Obtains informed consent from
client
1 2 3 4 5 6 7
Performance Survey
16
High
H
ig
h
Low
Lo
w
Performance
Im
p
o
rt
an
ce
High training focus area E!ective training system:
Maintain
Possibly redundant
training: Scale back
Maintain secondary
training focus
Importance-Performance Analysis
17
Importance Performance Results
Calculated immediately by facilitators using a pre-
programmed excel spreadsheet
Results plotted on importance performance grids
Interesting findings discussed immediately with
participants
Participant feedback collected for analysis and reporting
18
Data Entry and Analysis
19
Presenting Importance Performance Findings
20
Importance Performance Presentation
21
Importance Performance Interactive Exercise
A laminated scale placed across floor
Five tasks selected from the importance-performance
survey
Participants asked to stop next to point on scale
representing their individual rating of the team’s
perception of importance
Facilitators will guide discussion of team member
differences
Process repeated for rating and exploration of team
performance
22
Importance Performance Exercise
Section E
RNA:
Competency Assessment
Peter Johnson, CNM, PhD, FACNM
The material in this video is subject to the copyright of the owners of the material and is being provided for educational purposes under
rules of fair use for registered students in this course only. No additional copies of the copyrighted work may be made or distributed.
2
Case Study Related to Essential
Competencies
Knowledge
Assessment
—Higher Order
—Lower Order
What do I need to
know?
Things I need to
decide
Skills
Assessment
Things that I need
to do
Attitude
Assessment
Things that I am feeling
Team
Assessment
Who is team leader?
Why was team leader
selected?
How was team leader
selected?
Where were team
members assigned
and why?
Consultations among
team members (when,
who initiated, where,
why)
Environment
Assessment
Infrastructure and
equipment
Supplies and
medicines
Infrastructure
Logistics
Referrals
Competency Assessment
3
Team Processes
Team role play based on realistic case study
Tables
are used to represent facilities in the health care
system
Team elects a “team leader”
Providers are assigned to a “facility”
Resource and competency cards distributed to each
“facility”
Flip charts at each facility used to record competencies
and resources
4
Hospital
Table
Clinic
Table
Pharmacy
Table
Lab
Table
Competency
Flip
Chart
Competency
Flip Chart
Competency
Flip Chart
Competency
Flip Chart
Resource Flip
Chart
Resource Flip
Chart Resource Flip
Chart
Resource Flip
Chart
Team
Decision
Flip Chart
Competency Assessment Exercise Layout
5
Competency/Resource Cards
Competency
Feelings
Knowledge
Actions
Resources
Cadre
Infrastructure and equipment
Supplies and medications
6
Infrastructure and
Equipment
Hospital:
Infrastructure and
Equipment
Infrastructure and
Equipment
Private Counseling Room
——
Hospital I&E
Infrastructure and
Equipment
Medical Records Area
——
Hospital I&E
Infrastructure and
Equipment
Chairs
——
Hospital I&E
Infrastructure and
Equipment
Phlebotomy Area
——
Hospital I&E
Infrastructure and
Equipment
Examination Room
——
Hospital I&E
Infrastructure and
Equipment
Tables
——
Hospital I&E
Infrastructure and
Equipment
Exam Tables
——
Hospital I&E
Infrastructure and
Equipment
Waiting Room
——
Hospital I&E
Infrastructure and
Equipment
Reception
——
Hospital I&E
Infrastructure and
Equipment
Beds
——
Hospital I&E
Infrastructure and
Equipment
Workbench/Countertop
for Testing
——
Hospital I&E
7
Assessment of Actual Available Resources
Providers at each facility table are asked to consider
resources
Estimate number of providers within cadre available for
HIV service delivery area being explored
Estimate su!ciency/insu!ciency of infrastructure and
equipment, supplies and medications
8
Resource Data Collection
Physical Resources Hospital Clinic Pharmacy Laboratory
Infrastructure and Equipment A B A B A B A B
S I Used S I Used S I Used S I Used
Anti-diarrheal drugs
Beds
Centrifuge
Chairs
Cold boxes to transport blood samples
Computer
Drugs to treat skin rash
Electricity
Exam tables
Examination room
Fan or air conditioner
Filing cabinet
Medical records area
Phlebotomy area
Private counseling area
Reception
Record forms/data sheets in confidential envelope
Refrigerator
Sink
System for transferring blood to lab
Tables
9
Estimating System Resources
10
Competency Role Play
Facilitator plays standardized patient
Presents at table with scripted concern
Participants manage care at their table “facility” as they
believe appropriate
Time out called at point of referral to another facility
Participants post feelings, knowledge, and actions cards
based on their experience managing patient
Participants post infrastructure and equipment, supplies,
and medication cards
11
Collecting Competency Data
Stage of Service
Provision ! Key Feelings ! Key Knowledge ! Key Actions
Accepting or receptive Appropriate referral procedures
Answers client’s questions and refers to appropriate person,
as necessary
HIV Testing
At which facility
table was HIV
testing
conducted?
___Hospital
___Clinic
___Lab
___Pharmacy
___Not
conducted
Comfortable, relaxed, or at
ease Communication techniques Assures confidentiality
Confident, certain, or sure How to use rapid HIV test kit Appropriately collects blood sample for testing
Determined or intent Knowledge of rapid test storage Calls client by name
Understanding,
sympathetic, or concerned
Length of time or client to receive
results
Completes and stores all records and reports in secure place
with limited access
Process for receiving results Conducts rapid HIV test
Testing guidelines and standards
Confirms informed consent from client (and refers back to
counselor, if appropriate)
Universal precautions/
infection prevention measures Disposes instruments and medical wastes properly
Ensures universal precautions
Explains the testing procedures to the client
Explains that blood will be tested for HIV and other tests
Informs client about the safe elimination of bandages from
where blood sample is taken
Invites client to sit
Labels blood samples with appropriate identification
Refers to clinic for HIV post-test counseling and results
Treats client with respect
Uses appropriate hand hygiene
Underlines the need to come to the appointment to pick up
test results
Wears gloves
Score for HIV
Testing Stage ___ ticked out of 5 = ___% ___ ticked out of 8 = ___ % ___ ticked out of 19 = ___ %
12
Focus Group Discussion
A focus group discussion conducted immediately
following the competency assessment exercise explores:
! Feelings stimulated by exercise
! Knowledge needed to help patient
! Actions taken
! Resources needed
! Team dynamics
13
Facilitator Debriefing
Synthesis of observations
Synthesis of comments made by participants
Process evaluation
Fitting within a broader CHART and Country M&E
framework
14
Reporting
Local report prepared by lead facilitator and provided to
single point of contact within the community shortly
after RNA completion
CHART report sent to regional coordinating unit in
Kingston, Jamaica
CHART report used to enter qualitative and quantitative
data into a regional database
15
Next Steps
Data analysis plan
Use regional data to guide CHART training plan
Develop tools to measure other areas of service delivery
! Other HIV/AIDS, i.e., PMTCT
! Other IDs, i.e., malaria and tuberculosis
! Reproductive health
! Chronic diseases
16
Thank You
17
Lecture Evaluation
Your feedback on this lecture presentation is
very important and will be used for future
revisions. Please take a moment to evaluate
this lecture. The Evaluation link is available
on the lecture page.
Training Needs to Deliver a Basic Package of
Services
William Brieger, MPH, CHES, DrPH
Johns Hopkins University
The material in this video is subject to the copyright of the owners of the material and is being provided for educational purposes under
rules of fair use for registered students in this course only. No additional copies of the copyrighted work may be made or distributed.
Alma Ata Declaration
n Primary health care (PHC) is:
u Universally accessible to individuals
and families in the community
through their full participation
n Primary health care relies on:
u Health workers—including
physicians, nurses, midwives,
auxiliaries, community workers,
and traditional practitioners
u A response to the expressed needs
of the community
u The spirit of partnership and
service
n Ideally PHC should be based on
the perceived needs of the
community
n These, whether they be first
aid for farm accidents or
treatment of febrile children,
would form the basic package
of services from which training
would be designed
What Does the Community Want and Need?
3
n The reality is that PHC was quickly hijacked by health
professionals who wanted an efficient package of
effective services focusing on children, such as:
u Oral rehydration therapy
u Growth monitoring
u Breastfeeding promotion
u Immunization
u Family planning
Selective Primary Health Care
4
n Community-directed intervention (CDI) began in the mid-1900s with the annual
distribution of ivermectin to control river blindness (onchocerciasis)
n The basic concept is that:
u The health system provides training, supplies, supervision, and monitoring tools
u The community makes and carries out the major operational tasks of census,
volunteer selection (community-directed distributors—CDDs), volunteer support,
collection of supplies, submission of monitoring forms
n This approach is hybrid: selective in its focus on a particular disease and more broadly
PHC-oriented in its involvement of the community as a partner
Community-Directed Intervention
5
n CDI began with a one-
commodity package
(ivermectin)
n Health systems
opportunistically added
other tasks to community
responsibilities
n Eventually WHO
systematically tested
whether CDDs could
handle more tasks
CDI
6
n The “package” tested by WHO included:
u Ivermectin
u Malaria medicine
u ITNs
u Vitamin A
u DOTs for TB
Systematically Testing a CDI Package
7
n Integrated community case management (iCCM) has become a major way of delivering
treatment to children below five years of age who need timely and appropriate
management of:
u Malaria
u Diarrhea
u Acute respiratory illness, especially pneumonia
n This basic package is sometimes supplemented with:
u Deworming medicine
u Insecticide treated nets
n Being in the community does not guarantee that iCCM volunteers are selected
according to community participation principles
Integrated Community Case Management
8
n The World Bank Booster Program supported the MPP interventions in seven states in
Nigeria
n These MPP interventions consist of key maternal and child health interventions that
can reduce morbidity and mortality with marginal cost increase compared to malaria-
specific interventions alone
n The MPP can include up to 19 specific services ranging from specific commodities
(malaria medicines) to community health education
n Clearly not all can be incorporated at the start-up of a VHW/CHW training program
Malaria Plus Package (MPP) in Nigeria
9
n Increasing access to, and utilization of, preventive measures
n Expanding access to, and utilization of, effective diagnostic and treatment services
n Strengthening community mobilization and communication for behavior change
n Improving state- and municipality-specific monitoring and evaluation (M&E) for
evidence-based management
n Strengthening partnerships for resource mobilization and implementation
n Enhancing capacity of the states/municipalities for oversight and project coordination
Malaria Plus Includes …
10
n Once the basic or start-up package is
determined, one must use diagnostic
tools to review:
u Community perceptions
u Volunteer capacity
u National technical guidelines
n … Around the package components
Training Needs for a Package
11
n As we have seen, determining training needs can be open ended and based on
community defined and requested services
n Needs diagnosis can be based on a minimum care package that had been determined
for community health volunteers
n In either case, we need to learn about the trainee’s needs through:
u Interviews
u Review of documents
u Observation of performance
Summary
12
We provide professional writing services to help you score straight A’s by submitting custom written assignments that mirror your guidelines.
Get result-oriented writing and never worry about grades anymore. We follow the highest quality standards to make sure that you get perfect assignments.
Our writers have experience in dealing with papers of every educational level. You can surely rely on the expertise of our qualified professionals.
Your deadline is our threshold for success and we take it very seriously. We make sure you receive your papers before your predefined time.
Someone from our customer support team is always here to respond to your questions. So, hit us up if you have got any ambiguity or concern.
Sit back and relax while we help you out with writing your papers. We have an ultimate policy for keeping your personal and order-related details a secret.
We assure you that your document will be thoroughly checked for plagiarism and grammatical errors as we use highly authentic and licit sources.
Still reluctant about placing an order? Our 100% Moneyback Guarantee backs you up on rare occasions where you aren’t satisfied with the writing.
You don’t have to wait for an update for hours; you can track the progress of your order any time you want. We share the status after each step.
Although you can leverage our expertise for any writing task, we have a knack for creating flawless papers for the following document types.
Although you can leverage our expertise for any writing task, we have a knack for creating flawless papers for the following document types.
From brainstorming your paper's outline to perfecting its grammar, we perform every step carefully to make your paper worthy of A grade.
Hire your preferred writer anytime. Simply specify if you want your preferred expert to write your paper and we’ll make that happen.
Get an elaborate and authentic grammar check report with your work to have the grammar goodness sealed in your document.
You can purchase this feature if you want our writers to sum up your paper in the form of a concise and well-articulated summary.
You don’t have to worry about plagiarism anymore. Get a plagiarism report to certify the uniqueness of your work.
Join us for the best experience while seeking writing assistance in your college life. A good grade is all you need to boost up your academic excellence and we are all about it.
We create perfect papers according to the guidelines.
We seamlessly edit out errors from your papers.
We thoroughly read your final draft to identify errors.
Work with ultimate peace of mind because we ensure that your academic work is our responsibility and your grades are a top concern for us!
Dedication. Quality. Commitment. Punctuality
Here is what we have achieved so far. These numbers are evidence that we go the extra mile to make your college journey successful.
We have the most intuitive and minimalistic process so that you can easily place an order. Just follow a few steps to unlock success.
We understand your guidelines first before delivering any writing service. You can discuss your writing needs and we will have them evaluated by our dedicated team.
We write your papers in a standardized way. We complete your work in such a way that it turns out to be a perfect description of your guidelines.
We promise you excellent grades and academic excellence that you always longed for. Our writers stay in touch with you via email.