As a child I was agog at the admonition of the Soothsayer when he predicted the Mortality of Julius Caesar, who out of unmixed ostentation not singly discarded his education, but besides admonished him for the homogeneous. A homogeneous proportion can be drawn to the misportraiture that now surrounds Uttarakhand, the one separation entity, the ostentation and obliviousness of the Government has gravely pulverized the Narscold Exchequer and costed the lives of its own denizens, as resisting the mortality of one executive.
The reprove diversion, which is a certain by issue of perfect mishappening in our kingdom, has already begun, where twain the Central Government as polite as the Narscold Government are rebuking each other and their predecessors in chair for common prudence making, petty implementation, absence of save and alleviation temporization, steaming legitimate debates on whether the bestow method should be controlled beneath Entry 56 of the Union List or beneath Entry 17 of the Sate List, and the fashionable instigate free specialty “mis-governance”.
What lies on the other operative of this lamina is innumerable unreported mortalitys, wreck of common possessions, and counteract sixty thousand stranded race, who are yet to be afforded fullthing as remotely tranquillity to the promise “relief”. Genesis of the Problem and Observations made by the CAG Ment India boasts of entity ranked sixth in promises of largest hydel force offspring cleverness countries. Domestically, hydel force accounts for 1/4th of India’s assurance on breath.
The Hydel Force Ment of Uttarakoperative published in the year 2008, unconditionally acclaims that the Narscold has the virtual to impede closely 20,000 MW of electricity through hydel force. Blinded after a conjuncture such ambitious target, the Narscold Government failed to note, either unprejudicedly or inadequately, the very earliest external on the homogeneous page, which has been reproduced as: “To impede the environment cordial Renewable Breath resources and augment their subscription to the socioeconomic crop of the State. Another grave external which the Narscold conjuncture implementing the said plan, was oblivious to, is “To augment the use of breath sources that succor in corrective environmental defilement. ”
The popular policies, as the CAG Ment unconditionally points out, are aimed at provocative and not corrective environmental defilement, and entertain been a source of the floods in and encircling the portion. Periphrastically momentous, the ngoing damnation that was witnessed in Uttarakoperative was preordained in the ment published by the Comptroller and Auditor General of India as deceased as in 2009, reproaching the Central Government and the Government of Uttarakoperative for its dual role of common hydro force prudence making as polite as petty prudence implementation. Some of the ocean concerns talllighted in the CAG Ment are: 1. Due to the counteract ambitious prudence of the Narscold Government to compose multiple large stream channels, and multiple force plans on the homogeneous inferior, a thoughtful endangerment of environment is unquestionableness.
With counteract 42 Projects popularly functioning, and 203 plans in edifice and colliquation limit, at perfect 6 – 7 kms strain, there achieve be a dam to block the stream of the large stream. 2. All the plans are installed on tall seismic areas in and encircling districts chamoli, rudra prayag, pithoragarh, Almora and notwithstanding sarcastic globe quakes in 1720, 1803, 1991, and 1999 the reproduction of hydro force plans, after a conjunctureout extended divergent seismic measures abide to run swindler thereby causing thoughtful cause to the lives of the race. 3. There is a apparent conjunction of Scintillate Floods which would product in sarcastic damnation to existence and possessions in and encircling the low untrue areas of the hills. Consideration Appended to the Ment has exalt talllighted sundry entreatys wherein such scintillate floods entertain occurred previously in the homogeneous areas. 4. No proof to hint that for want to forego after a conjuncture the provisions of Environmental Contact Assessment, a amercement was setd on the builders.
5. Want of the nodal performance to secure resignation of quarterly and half per-annum obedience ments by the skill. . Flagive Carelessness towards Environmental and Security Concerns. 7. The inappropriate contact on the ecology was exalt beneathscored by the deed that closely 4 out of 5 Force Projects entertain shown the thorough arefaction up of large stream beds to a distil producting into sarcastic enervation and wreck of the ecology, and imcounteract in the inspire consideration producting into arefaction up of normal aquifers in the nearby areas. 8. According to International Standards, the minimum bestow-away of large stream downstream should be oceantained at 75 % so that the aquatic existence trash uncontaminated.
However, the bestow plans are discharging downstream large stream by 90 % and aloft which products into thorough wreck of the aquatic existence. 9. Common Pre-Feasibility Survey Reports, which gives defective axioms for evaluation of the hydro force place, which resources thoughtful less comings in ascertaining whether the precipitation to invent is permissible or not, interrogations on stock succeedingness and what would be the contact of begrime erosion, etc. reocean in a narscold of thoughtful peril. 10. As ample as 38 % of the entirety plans which entertain been supposing an Environmental Colliquation entertain failed to heave out mandatory stockation. By – Passing The Law As per the Gazette generally-knownation issued by the Central Government beneath Sections 2 and 3 of the Environment Protection Act, 1986, the area outside the large stream Bhagirathi from Gaumukh to Uttarkashi, which is 135 kms strain, was avowed to be “eco sentient area”. A entirety area of encircling 4179. 59 sq km came beneath the eco-sentient zone.
This achieve set tranquillityrictions on quarrying, commissioning hydroforce plans on Bhagirathi, and edifice of roads in the prohibited area. Besides, it achieve set a ban on felling of trees and enhancement up of deedories to fabrication goods and other wooden items. For the purposes of potent implementation, the Narscold Government, after a conjuncture the aid of the topical NGO’s and race was mandated to formudeceased a Zonal Master Plan outside the area, whereby perfect hydel force which is beneath 20 MW of Force Offspring Cleverness had to bring-encircling a colliquation from the Narscold Ministry.
However, the Narscold Government divergent the said generally-knownation in May as they were not “consulted” antecedently this prudence was formulated; incompact concerns voiced by the citizens that an stoppage on crop would bestow them end to the Stone Age, which in substantiality was not what the generally-knownation envisaged. This interchangeable reprove diversion and inter-ministerial refuse entertain led to such misportraiture. Today the very area outside Bhagirathi and cleverness of Uttarkashi are the defeat hit areas of the State.
Travesty of Environmental Clearance. Another generally-knownation issued by the Central Government warrants choice. It was mandated that antecedently sanctioning the plans, or antecedently expanding or modernizing hitherto strong plans, it was unbefitting to bring-encircling an Environmental Contact Assessment Colliquation from the Central Government and the Narscold Government. Perfect Hydel Force plan was subjected to the homogeneous strictures as entertain been mandated beneath Section 3(1) and Section 3(2) (v) of the Environment Protection Act, 1986.
Such an EIA has to be in specimen after a conjuncture the Standards laid down by the National Environment Policy, and the guidelines that entertain been made beneath Rule 5 of the Environment Protection Rules. There are foul-mouthed limits antecedently procuring an Environmental Clearance: 1. Screening wherein the plans are disconnected into two categories, those to be assessed by the Central Government (Category A Projects which are counteract and aloft 25 MW cleverness force plans), and those to be assessed by the Narscold Government (Under 25 MW Cleverness Force Projects). 2. Scoping by which the Expert Committee determines on inferential concerns (popular and inferable) in-reference-to Environmental Depletion or impairment, at which limit the Committee is empowered to remit or refuse the contact seeking opening of the plan.
3. Common Consideration which provides for a common consideration held in the auspices of the birth, accomplish responses of all sbring-encircling holders, villagers, etc. in fitness and to be supervised by the Narscold Defilement Control Board, but which specifically excludes “modernization of irrigation plans” out of its territory. . Appraisal which resources the inferential sifting by the Expert Appraisal Committee or Narscold Level Expert Appraisal Committee of the contact and other documents relish the Final EIA ment, fruit of the common considerations including common hearing proceedings, submitted by the suitor to the regulatory antecedent concerned for give of environmental colliquation. In tranquillityoration to the aforementioned checks and counteracts, there is a interrupted Post Environment Colliquation monitoring which are to be submitted on a half per-annum account by the skill.
This provides a very chubby paint of the law that governs such colliquations; nevertheless the substantiality is far from such opinion. For entreaty, according to the Ment of the Comptroller and Auditor General of India, as ample as 38 % of the entirety industries and plans functioning in the area, and which entertain ordinary a crude saline to work, entertain not complied after a conjuncture the mandatory stockation of trees in and encircling the birth.
This has producted into thoughtful deforeplace in the abrupt areas, which products into begrime erosion. Himalayas entity boyish inclose mountains, entertain a very unsconsideration begrime compaction, as compared to other mountain ranges, besource of which begrime erosion can usurp cataclysmic proportions, it is besides the infer why large streams are changing their normal sequence and disappointing low crevices in the hills, wreaking damnation incompactst those who exist in its way. Are we to reprove?
This is one incessant interrogation, which warrants a greedy introspection. Reports entertain besides hinted that illicit edifice of motels, tranquillity houses, visitor houses, hotels and tranquillityaurants entertain been made in the large stream bed, since a generally-knownation issued by the Narscold Government apparently prohibits any illicit edifice in or encircling 100 metres from the large stream bed. This is supplementary to the impairment that has already been carried out by the Government.
Media ments exalt stipudeceased that there was no potent functioning antecedent in the call of “State Disaster Skill Authority”. The ventilate interrogation that now faces us is whether this mishap was “natural” at all, or was it brought encircling by our own fallacies, inactions, unprejudiced obliviousness, and carelessness. History is supplied after a conjuncture entreatys of civilizations racket beneath the sway of Normal Forces, and after a conjuncture the bestow scold of depletion, the coming of the Upper Gangetic Basin and the Himalayas hangs in a very subtle counteract.