|
Criteria
|
Levels of Achievement
|
|
|
Content
|
|
|
|
Advanced
|
|
|
|
Proficient
|
|
|
|
Developing
|
|
|
|
Not Present
|
|
|
|
Points Earned
|
|
Analysis of Material
|
32 to 35 points
All elements of the assigned topic are clearly and completely addressed in light of 5–7-page requirement. Analyses flow in a logical and effective manner, address all elements of the assignment thoroughly, and reach the nuances of the issues raised. Complex issues are navigated with precision, clarity, and detail.
|
29 to 31 points
Major elements of the assigned topic are discussed in a meaningful way, but the paper would benefit from additional clarity, depth, or detail. Analyses are generally well constructed and complex issues are recognized.
|
1 to 28 points
Some elements of the assigned topic are mentioned, but the discussion is incomplete, unclear, superficial, or otherwise does not meet expectations. Analyses are general and lacking in depth. Complex issues and nuances are overlooked.
|
0 points
Assigned elements are not discussed.
|
|
Organization
|
32 to 35 points
The paper is focused and well organized. The paper has a clear thesis, and a clear and substantive introduction and conclusion. The paper effectively uses headings and subheadings, as appropriate, to focus and deepen analyses.
|
29 to 31 points
The paper is reasonably well organized and follows a logical path from idea to idea and section to section. The paper includes an adequate introduction and conclusion.
|
1 to 28 points
The paper is in need of additional organization and clarity. Ideas and/or sections of the paper either do not flow logically, or are in need of fundamental improvement. The paper is lacking an adequate introduction and/or conclusion.
|
0 points
The paper lacks an introduction, conclusion, and meaningful organization.
|
Content
Advanced
Proficient
Developing
Not Present
Points Earned
|
Evaluation, Synthesis, and Adequate Use of Sources
|
32 to 35 points
Sources, concepts and ideas are evaluated critically and synthesized in a manner that moves beyond restatement and makes a valuable contribution to the assigned topic.
|
29 to 31 points
Sources are used correctly and support the paper’s analyses and conclusions. Concepts and ideas are understood and linked in a reasonable way that supports the paper’s conclusions. Paper reflects a good familiarity with the major ideas, but would benefit from greater critical evaluation and synthesis.
|
1 to 28 points
Some sources are used, but are not critically evaluated and/or are not used in an effective manner. Paper would benefit from a more substantive use of sources, more appropriate reliance on sources, and/or better skill in evaluating, synthesizing, or applying ideas, concepts, or sources.
|
0 points
Sources are not used; ideas and concepts from sources are not evaluated or synthesized.
|
|
|
Structure
|
Advanced
Proficient
Developing
Not Present
Points Earned
|
Mechanics
|
14 to 15 points
No grammar, spelling, or punctuation errors are present. Writing is precise and word choice is appropriate.
|
12 to 13 points
Few grammar, spelling, or punctuation errors are present. Writing style is sufficient and word choice is adequate.
|
1 to 11 points
Several grammar, spelling, or punctuation errors are present. Writing style is understandable but could be improved. Word choice is generally good.
|
0 points
Numerous spelling, grammar, or punctuation errors are present. Writing style is difficult to understand and word choice is poor.
|
Structure
Advanced
Proficient
Developing
Not Present
Points Earned
|
Current APA Format Elements
|
14 to 15 points
Citations and format are in current APA style. Cover page, bibliography, etc. are correctly formatted. Paper is double-spaced with 1-inch margins and written in 12 point Times New Roman font.
|
12 to 13 points
Citations and format are in current APA style with few errors. Cover page, bibliography, etc. are present with few errors. Paper is double-spaced with 1-inch margins and written in 12 point Times New Roman font.
|
1 to 11 points
Citations and format are in current APA style, though several errors are present. Cover page, bibliography, etc., are included, though several errors are present. Paper is double-spaced, but margins or font are incorrect.
|
0 points
Citations are not formatted correctly. Cover page, bibliography, etc. are not included or formatted incorrectly. Paper is not double-spaced, margins are incorrect, or font is incorrect.
|
|
Research Elements
|
14 to 15 points
At least 4–7 high quality primary and secondary sources are utilized in a mature and effective manner. Research effectively incorporates multiple nuanced viewpoints of complex issues. Adequate number of sources (per assignment instructions) are used. A complete and accurate bibliography is provided. Arguments are correctly and effectively supported by research.
|
12 to 13 points
Primary and secondary sources of acceptable and appropriate nature and quality are utilized. Research reflects multiple viewpoints of complex issues. Adequate number of sources (Per assignment instructions) are used. A complete and accurate bibliography is provided. Arguments are acceptably supported by research.
|
1 to 11 points
Fewer than the 4 sources of acceptable and appropriate nature and quality are utilized. Research does not reflect multiple viewpoints of complex issues. An incomplete or inaccurate bibliography is provided. Arguments are tangentially supported with research. Arguments incorporate research but often include or rely upon personal opinion without appropriate support. Sources are used inappropriately at times.
|
0 points
Appropriate sources are not used, or sources are lacking entirely. Arguments are not supported by research. Opposing viewpoints are dismissed or ignored. Bibliography is incomplete or missing.
|
|
Total
|
/150
|
