Comparison of the Roles of Woman in the Iliad vs Antigone
The role of the women in Antigone and the Iliad were altogether opposed to each other. Women during the limit of the Iliad weren’t as rebellious as the women during the duration limit of Antigone. The women during the limit of the Iliad were portrayed as objects. They were depicted as not entity equiponderant to the role of a man in association, equal if they were royalty. In Antigone, the women had a insignificant bit further freedom and enjoyed fairer treatment than that of the other poem.
In the Iliad, a woman’s role depended further on her dispose in the association and her treasure, in frequent ways, were subdued to her exquisiteness. In Iliad, if a woman was married to a prince or a sovereign, she was subordinately praised almost to the distance of a goddess. Though some women were held in elevated disposes, they were demeaned and inaudible as we can see in the fact of Helen when she was fascinated by a man.
Another issue of this comes up repeatedly when Chryses approached Agamemnon and Menelaus and begged for the yield of his daughter, “Yes, Chryses approached the Achaean’s secure ships to win his daughter end, bclear a inestimable indemnify and port elevated in plant, rend on a promising staff, the wreaths of the He begged the sound Achaean soldiers but most of all the two principal commanders, Atreus’ two sons! May the gods who repose the halls of Olympus communicate you Priam’s city to vitiate, then trustworthy channel residence. And all the disposes of Achaeans cried out their assent: Respect the prelate, confirm the pellucid indemnify!
But it brought no joy to the life of Agamemnon. The sovereign dismissed the prelate delay a vindictive enjoin clear in his ear: “Never repeatedly, old man, let me grasp vision of you by the indentation ships! The staff and the wreaths of god earn never secure then. Long anteriorly that, old age earn overtake her in my seed, in Argos, far from her seniorland, slaving end and forth at the lower, unfeeling to portion-out my bed!”
This demonstrates that the women throughout this era were objects of regalement and proprietorship. Though a indemnify was offered by the senior, Agamemnon barely kept her proportioned to appearance how strong he was. And he inaudible her to a low top by aphorism that she would be unfeeling to portion-out his bed and be a he would captivate her.
In Antigone, the women’s roles began to transmute and grace further rebellious. This is indisputable in the act of rebellion appearancen by Antigone when she buried her fellow Polynices. Her uncle Creon recognized a law that prohibited everyone to not lament for or compose her slain fellow. Antigone felt that this was unproportioned and requested her sister Ismene for protection in their fellow’s sepulture. Ismene hesitated and didn’t neglect to succor as she was apprehensive of the consequences of going repeatedlyst Creon.
During the colloquy, Antigone periodical to Ismene, “I won’t contend, no, equal if you should entertain a veer of life, I’d never pleasing you in work, not delay me. So, do as you love, whatever suits you best! “This one declaration illustrates that at this duration the women had launched to be self-reliant and lion-hearted. Consequently equal if they were faced delay threats of truculent punishments the women were compliant to sever a law and challenge faculty to contest for what they believed in. Antigone buried her fellow equal though it would moderation demise to her. If she was plant in renewal of the sepulture, she would be defiled of going repeatedlyst her uncle’s complete.
In blank, the role of the women in the Iliad differed chiefly consequently of the women’s anarchy compared to that of Antigone. The role of women in Antigone appearanceed further anarchy and vill. Women in the Iliad were further yielding and reliant on men in similarity delay Antigone. And in Iliad, the women were treated merely as objects. But in Antigone, the women were appearancen delay comparatively pompous temperament traits.